I put a proposal before Parliament and the Senate this year because of one observation from thirty years around Canadian capital markets: the first check a startup cashes determines almost everything that follows.
The money matters. The network attached to the money matters more.
Every check carries investors, buyers, bankers, lawyers, and talent. When an American fund writes the first check for a Canadian founder, that founder enters an American ecosystem on day one. The Series A follows the relationships. So does the Series B. So does the acquirer.
For the last fifty years, the second check has come from outside the country. That stopped being a quirk and became the operating system.
The Ownership Transfer Runs on a Schedule
Here is the sequence I keep describing to policymakers. The grant is Canadian. The lab is Canadian. The founder is Canadian. Then the round closes somewhere else, and the upside boards a plane with the network attached to it.
The data confirms the sequence. CVCA analysis shows U.S. investor participation climbs directly with round size: 18.7 percent in deals under $5 million, rising to 66 percent participation in deals above $50 million. At the growth stage, mixed Canadian-American syndicates account for 83.8 percent of rounds.
Control migrates even when the office stays. Research covered by BetaKit found that while 93 percent of acquired Canadian companies kept a domestic presence, leadership and strategic decision-making shifted abroad in 28 of 30 firms studied. The Canadian entity becomes an R&D shop. The decisions on IP, commercialization, and long-term growth get made in another country.
The semiconductor file shows how current this is. CentML, Hyperlume, Tenstorrent, and Untether AI either moved south or sold to American buyers, with CentML going to Nvidia in a deal reportedly topping $400 million USD. Each of those companies started with Canadian research and Canadian talent.
Capital Follows Incentive Structure
You run a business. You know capital moves toward the best after-tax risk/reward equation, wherever it sits. Founders behave the same way. Asking them to raise at home out of loyalty is asking them to run their companies badly.
So the correction has to happen in the incentive structure, at the exact moment the first check gets written.
Canada already built the mechanism. Flow-through shares have financed strategically important, high-risk activity for decades. In 2023-2024, flow-through shares accounted for more than 65 percent of exploration financing on the TSX Venture Exchange. The architecture works. It just stops at the edge of the resource sector.
The UK took the same principle and pointed it at innovation. Its Enterprise Investment Scheme has run for more than three decades. In the 2024-25 tax year, 3,735 companies raised £1,575 million through EIS. Britain evaluated the model, adjusted it, and expanded it. That is what a mature economy does with an instrument that performs.
The Ask: A $500 Million Test, Three Years, Measured Hard
My pre-budget submission asks for a capped pilot. Extend flow-through shares to Canadian technology startups in AI, quantum computing, biotechnology, and advanced manufacturing. Up to $500 million annually in qualifying expenditures, financed by private investors’ risk capital, for three years.
The design discipline matters as much as the mechanism:
-
Government sets eligibility rules and guardrails. It selects zero portfolio companies.
-
Canadian private investors choose which startups earn their capital and carry the risk.
-
The ceiling constrains renunciations nationally. This is a cap on eligible expenditures, and it falls well short of $500 million in government spending.
-
One primary performance measure: additional private capital mobilized per dollar of federal tax expenditure.
-
After three years, the options are explicit. Expand, continue, redesign, or end.
A willingness to kill the program if it fails the additionality test is part of the case for running it.
This Is Ownership Policy, Written as Tax Policy
A Canadian writing the first check makes it far more likely the corporation starts here and stays here, because the network that arrives with that check is a Canadian network. The follow-on investors, the board members, the bankers all sit inside the country where the company has to make its hardest decisions.
“Buy Canadian” should extend past the checkout counter and into the capitalization table. Canadians who accept the risk of backing a qualifying startup should own a piece of the upside when it works.
The policy question in front of Parliament stays narrow and testable. Make the Canadian first check financially competitive, and more Canadian companies get born here, commercialize here, and build their financing path here before another country builds it for them.
That is the mechanism. The cost of waiting is already on the record.
Learn more @ https://canflowthrough.com/own-canadian/ read it, challenge it, add your voice.